While Judy Grady's work had admirable aspects, it also contain point of views that I could not agree with. Specifically, the idea that all men treat women in this specific fashion and the condescending tone in which Grady delivers her message. The belief that all people, regardless of their gender behave the same, is completely incorrect. The compiling of many people is an incorrect way of addressing a problem, and could be detrimental to creating the solution. Furthermore, the way in which Grady addresses the people who are accidentally included into her target audience is quite condescending, which does not help move the emotions of the wrongfully accused to support the ideas of Grady. The approach Grady would have had to of taken to take my admiration completely would have been either specifically calling out the spouses who behave in this manner, or speaking to those who do not commit these offenses in a less degrading manner.
"I Want a Wife" relates to Medea in a few different points. First off, Grady speaks of the struggles of women. The struggles of women are one of the major themes in Medea with Medea facing an unwarranted divorce and the family fallout that will follow. These struggles are not necessarily due to the fault of women, but the world antagonizing them by strict stereotypes and giving an unbalanced amount of power to the men. Regardless, these struggles are both depicted in Grady's and Euripides's works. Another similarity in the works is the belief that the women will take the children, and just accept the wishes of the man from a divorce. Medea is to be exiled and to take her children with her after Jason decides to marry the princess. This punishment is nearly identical to what Grady describes will happen to women after divorces in the 1970's. These similarities both show how until the late 1990's to early 2000's women faced similar disadvantages in different cultures and times.
Nice insights here, Gunnar. I like your thoughts on the tone of the work, and you make some interesting comparisons. P.S. The author's name is Judy Brady, not Judy Grady . . .
ReplyDelete